We are ready to serve you with a free virtual consultation during the COVID-19 outbreak. Click Here for more information.

Determining Fault in a Car Accident by Location of Damage

When Is Someone Other Than the Driver at Fault for a Single-Car Accident?

Many factors determine fault in a car accident. Usually, an insurance adjuster will come to one determination of fault by looking at the evidence from the outside. However, drivers can appeal an insurance adjuster’s decision if they believe the decision is wrong.

If you were in a car accident and need to determine fault, reach out to a car accident lawyer to help you gather the requisite evidence. To get started, read through this article to learn how to determine fault and how to prove it in your situation.

Why Is Fault Important?

Fault determines who will recover compensation for injuries and other losses after a car accident. It also determines how much each person could potentially recover.

Every State has different rules regarding how fault affects a car accident settlement.

The most common system States apply is the modified comparative fault rule. Under this rule, a person can recover damages if they are less than 50 percent or 51 percent at fault for the accident, depending on the specific rules of the State.

How Is Fault Determined in a Car Accident?

In a typical car accident, insurance adjusters from one or both insurance companies with clients in the crash usually gather witness statements, photos or videos of the accident scene, and accident restaging experts to determine what happened.

They might use:

  • The speed each driver was traveling at the time of the accident;
  • What the weather and road conditions were like;
  • The location and severity of any tire marks;
  • Whether everyone had working headlights and brakes; and
  • If any of the drivers were distracted or under the influence of alcohol or drugs.

Insurance adjusters assign a percentage of fault to each driver involved in a case based on this evidence. They then usually make an offer to the injured party or parties. It is at this point that an injured party can reject the offer or appeal the insurance adjuster’s determination regarding their fault in the crash.

Using Location of Damage to Determine Fault

There are some situations in which the location of the damage to the vehicles involved makes it obvious who was at fault. For example, if your car was rear-ended, you have damage to the back of your car, and the other driver has damage to the front of their car. Rear-end collisions are usually the fault of the rear driver, so if this is the case in your accident, you can likely use the location of the damage to prove that you were not at fault.

In another example, say you were driving through a parking lot when someone backed into you. In this case, if the damage is in the middle of your car and the rear of the other driver’s car, the other driver is likely at fault since they backed into you and weren’t paying attention to what was behind them. However, if the damage is to the front of your car, it may be harder to prove that the other driver was fully at fault, as you may have had time to stop before the collision occurred.

The location of the damage is not always a clear indicator of fault. If you were turning left at a stoplight and another car ran into you, causing damage to the left side of your car, fault is harder to determine. Was one of the drivers running a red light? Who had the right of way in this situation? The answer is not as clear in such a situation.

What to Do After a Car Accident to Help Determine Fault

After a car accident that wasn’t your fault, preserve any evidence that someone else’s negligence may have caused.

Joseph L. Benson II, Esq.
Car Accident Attorney, Joseph L. Benson II, Esq.

In order to do this:

  • Immediately after the collision, pull over to the side of the road if you can still move your car.
  • Call an ambulance if anyone is injured, and call the police to report the accident and get their written report on the circumstances of the crash.
  • If you can move safely and without making any injuries worse, take photos of the accident scene, damage to your car, damage to the other car(s), and any injuries involved.
  • Ask witnesses what they saw and get their contact information in case you need to talk to them again later.
  • Keep records of repairs done to your car, along with any relevant medical records.
  • Get in touch with a car accident lawyer to help you prove fault in your case.

Proving fault by location of damage could be very helpful in your car accident claim. If you were recently in a car accident that was caused by someone else’s negligence, you should contact a car accident lawyer to help you prove fault. Car accident attorneys have worked for years with claims like yours and know exactly what evidence they need to prove fault and recover damages.

Benson and Bingham